Ideas for a shelter, teen center, skating rink revival, and even a bank flood social media

BUCYRUS, OH — The fate of the former YMCA building continues to stir discussion, not just in City Council meetings but also among residents who have taken to social media to share their thoughts. From practical business proposals to nostalgic hopes for a revived skating rink, the community is buzzing with ideas — but not everyone agrees on what should happen next.

City Officials Push Back on Initial Reports

Before diving into public suggestions, the conversation surrounding the YMCA building started with a debate over the actual costs of maintaining it.

An initial article published by Crawford County Now led to frustration from city officials, who felt key details were misrepresented or omitted. Specifically, while the report correctly stated that physical damage coverage for the building would cost $5,935 per year with a $25,000 deductible, it failed to mention that adding liability coverage would not cost the city anything extra.

Additionally, the report listed January’s electric bill at $97 and the gas bill at $239, but city officials noted these figures were misleadingly annualized. The higher utility usage resulted from contractors being on-site for inspections, not from regular building operations. If the city were to accept the donation, officials stated they would winterize the building, significantly reducing or eliminating these ongoing costs.

The article has since been corrected to reflect the full financial picture.

A Place to Help People or Just More Parking?

With those clarifications in mind, the public discussion quickly shifted from finances to what the building could or should be used for.

Some residents, like Mary Q., believe the building should be converted into a homeless shelter or warming center, pointing out that Crawford County lacks many options for those in need. Deb V. expanded on this idea, suggesting it could serve as a safe space for the homeless during frigid nights, offering warm meals, socks, and dry clothing. However, Diana G. questioned the feasibility, noting that shelters require significant funding and ongoing support to operate.

Meanwhile, others, like Nicholas A., believe the building’s fate has already been decided, stating, “Everyone has great ideas for this building that would help people, instead, the fire department needs parking.” Steve M. echoed this frustration, saying the city may end up buying land elsewhere for a new fire station while this property sits unused.

A Business Opportunity or Just Another Empty Lot?

Some residents are thinking outside the box. Earl J. claims to have a business proposal specifically for the building and is looking to arrange a meeting. Others, like Debra P., think it could be repurposed into a brewery and restaurant, while Jay F. suggests turning it into a sober living house for people struggling with addiction.

However, not everyone is convinced that repurposing the building is the right move. Thomas R. and Josh T. suggested the city demolish the building entirely and create a park. Others joked that Bucyrus should stick to what it does best, with Ian H. sarcastically suggesting, “Pleeeeaaase turn it into another bank or gas station.”

What Happens Next?

While City Council has rejected the building for now, the conversation about its future is far from over. With strong opinions on both sides — some seeing an opportunity to invest in the community and others viewing it as an unnecessary burden — the fate of the former YMCA remains uncertain.

One thing is clear: Bucyrus residents have no shortage of ideas. The question is, will any of them become a reality?