Skip to content

FreeWire Magazine

Connecting Voices, Amplifying Truth.

Primary Menu
  • Home
  • News
    • Local
    • National
    • Politics
    • Community
    • Crime
    • Entertainment
  • Sports
  • Obituaries
  • Events
  • Watch & Listen
  • About Us
  • Contact

New Charges Filed Against Crestline Man Accused of Killing Parents

Logan Andrew Published: January 31, 2026 | Updated: February 18, 2026 2 minutes read

By Kim Gasuras | FreeWire — Your News, Your Voice

Maxwell Anatra’s mugshot from the Crawford County Justice Center

BUCYRUS—A Crestline man charged with the murders of his parents is facing additional charges after incidents allegedly occurred with staff at the Crawford County Justice Center.

Maxwell Anatra, 24, who is already facing 11 counts in connection with the incident that took place at the home of his parents, Lisa and Lindsey Anatra, on Nov. 18, has been indicted by the Crawford County grand jury on six counts in a separate case.

The indictment alleges that on Jan. 2, Anatra caused or attempted to cause physical harm to a Crawford County Sheriff’s deputy, a sergeant, and two correctional officers, and made threats against the deputy. It is also alleged that he caused or attempted to cause physical harm to yet another correctional officer on Jan. 17.

Anatra is currently being housed at the Crawford County Justice Center and has been formally charged with one count of fourth-degree assault, four counts of fifth-degree felony assault, and one misdemeanor charge of aggravated menacing.

As in Anatra’s original case, Crawford County Common Pleas Judge Sean Leuthold has recused himself; the new case will be overseen by Visiting Judge Daniel T. Hogan of Franklin County by assignment from the Ohio Supreme Court. Lisa Anatra was previously employed as a domestic relations case manager at the Crawford County Courthouse under Leuthold.

Anatra is scheduled to appear via video in Crawford County Common Pleas Court on Feb. 4 at 1 p.m. to be arraigned on the new charges. He is being represented by Mansfield attorney James Mayer III.

Charges in Anatra’s original case include:

  • Two counts of aggravated murder and two counts of murder (unclassified felonies).
  • Three counts of aggravated burglary and one count of aggravated robbery (first-degree felonies, one with a gun specification).
  • Two counts of theft of a firearm and one count of tampering with evidence (third-degree felonies, two with gun specifications).

About The Author

Logan Andrew's avatar

Logan Andrew

See author's posts

What do you feel about this?

Post navigation

Previous: (UPDATE: Prosecutor Issues Statement) GUILTY VERDICT: Outlaw Biker Convicted in Fatal 2024 Clubhouse Shooting
Next: Dorothy D. Emerson

Author's Other Posts

The Mid-Month Blotter Check-In: Flowers, Fever, and the Frays in the Fabric Bucyrus Badge Blotter Template (1)

The Mid-Month Blotter Check-In: Flowers, Fever, and the Frays in the Fabric

May 14, 2026 1
Crawford County Unofficial 2026 Primary Election Results Your paragraph text

Crawford County Unofficial 2026 Primary Election Results

May 14, 2026 0
BREAKING: Armed Suspect Identified in Overnight Standoff on East Warren Street; Gunshots Fired at Officers 8aea53b3-8ed5-432c-bf5f-afe0646b7662

BREAKING: Armed Suspect Identified in Overnight Standoff on East Warren Street; Gunshots Fired at Officers

May 11, 2026 1
The Ashes of Apathy: A Final Warning

The Ashes of Apathy: A Final Warning

May 4, 2026 1

Related Stories

704367229_1389829253185607_1718669921932143979_n
2 minutes read

Bucyrus Public Library Kicks Off Dinosaur-Themed Summer Reading Program

Kimberly Gasuras June 5, 2026 0
img_0714-1.jpg
3 minutes read

Bucyrus Historical Society to Host Special Colonel Crawford Portrayal

FreeWire Staff May 20, 2026 0
29ec7c53060d4ef3833c8b78efea6ee8-1.jpg
3 minutes read

Crestline Girl Advances to Top Five in National Junior Ranger Competition

Kimberly Gasuras May 16, 2026 0
73d3f5c2-2bed-4c1d-af50-8673f631e17e
2 minutes read

Industry and Education Collide: Bucyrus Mobile Workforce Day Brings Careers to Campus

FreeWire Staff May 16, 2026 0
Bucyrus Badge Blotter Template (1)
4 minutes read

The Mid-Month Blotter Check-In: Flowers, Fever, and the Frays in the Fabric

Logan Andrew May 14, 2026 1
Your paragraph text
2 minutes read

Crawford County Unofficial 2026 Primary Election Results

Logan Andrew May 14, 2026 0

Trending Now

Bucyrus Public Library Kicks Off Dinosaur-Themed Summer Reading Program 704367229_1389829253185607_1718669921932143979_n 1

Bucyrus Public Library Kicks Off Dinosaur-Themed Summer Reading Program

June 5, 2026 0
Bucyrus Historical Society to Host Special Colonel Crawford Portrayal img_0714-1.jpg 2

Bucyrus Historical Society to Host Special Colonel Crawford Portrayal

May 20, 2026 0
Crestline Girl Advances to Top Five in National Junior Ranger Competition 29ec7c53060d4ef3833c8b78efea6ee8-1.jpg 3

Crestline Girl Advances to Top Five in National Junior Ranger Competition

May 16, 2026 0
Industry and Education Collide: Bucyrus Mobile Workforce Day Brings Careers to Campus 73d3f5c2-2bed-4c1d-af50-8673f631e17e 4

Industry and Education Collide: Bucyrus Mobile Workforce Day Brings Careers to Campus

May 16, 2026 0

You may have missed

704367229_1389829253185607_1718669921932143979_n
2 minutes read

Bucyrus Public Library Kicks Off Dinosaur-Themed Summer Reading Program

Kimberly Gasuras June 5, 2026 0
img_0714-1.jpg
3 minutes read

Bucyrus Historical Society to Host Special Colonel Crawford Portrayal

FreeWire Staff May 20, 2026 0
29ec7c53060d4ef3833c8b78efea6ee8-1.jpg
3 minutes read

Crestline Girl Advances to Top Five in National Junior Ranger Competition

Kimberly Gasuras May 16, 2026 0
73d3f5c2-2bed-4c1d-af50-8673f631e17e
2 minutes read

Industry and Education Collide: Bucyrus Mobile Workforce Day Brings Careers to Campus

FreeWire Staff May 16, 2026 0
  • Home
  • News
  • Sports
  • Obituaries
  • Events
  • Watch & Listen
  • About Us
  • Contact
Copyright © 2026 All rights reserved. Made by Small Town Marketing