BUCYRUS, OH — A Crawford County man has been sentenced to nearly five years in prison following one of the most disturbing cases of animal neglect the area has seen in recent memory.
Patrick Grasley, 23, of Bucyrus, was sentenced Tuesday to 59 months in prison after pleading guilty to felony charges stemming from the discovery of two deceased dogs found locked in a cage inside a detached garage at his residence. The dogs were discovered in a severely decomposed state after an anonymous tip led sheriff’s deputies to the property on May 29.
Investigators say the animals had clearly attempted to dig their way out of the cage before succumbing to starvation. Grasley admitted to authorities that the dogs had been dead for some time and that he disposed of their remains in a burn barrel just one day before deputies arrived.
The case quickly moved from municipal court to the Crawford County Common Pleas Court, where Grasley faced two felony charges:
- Cruelty to animals, a fifth-degree felony, carrying up to 12 months in prison.
- Tampering with evidence, a third-degree felony, carrying up to 36 months.
Judge Sean Leuthold handed down a 59-month sentence, citing the graphic and tragic nature of the case. Grasley had already been in custody since his arrest and was given credit for time served.
In court, Grasley attempted to shift blame, suggesting he lacked the resources to care for the animals and claiming he didn’t know what to do. But prosecutors pushed back, stating that Grasley had steady employment through a temp agency and access to pet food. Kalmbach Feeds, where Grasley was assigned through a staffing service, released a public statement making it clear he was not a direct employee and rejected any implication that he didn’t have the means to provide basic care for the animals.
Community reaction has been swift and severe, with local residents calling the case “sickening” and “infuriating.” Social media posts show an outpouring of support for stronger animal cruelty laws and stricter monitoring of neglect reports.
The Crawford County Humane Society did not immediately respond to a request for comment but has previously partnered with local officials to advocate for harsher penalties in cases of severe neglect or abuse.
With Grasley now sentenced, some are hopeful this case will be a turning point — not just in raising awareness, but in sending a clear message: Neglect isn’t an excuse. It’s a crime.
