by Logan Andrew | FreeWire Magazine
DELAWARE, OH — Adam Stone, a former Bucyrus attorney, has been sentenced to 54 months in state prison after pleading guilty to felony charges stemming from a years-long scheme in which he deceived a Crawford County couple about the investigation into their son’s death. The sentence, delivered Tuesday morning by Delaware County Common Pleas Judge James P. Schuck, orders Stone to serve consecutive prison terms for telecommunications fraud and impersonating a peace officer. Stone, 41, was immediately taken into custody, capping a protracted legal saga that saw him fall from a respected local lawyer to a convicted felon.
Background of the Case
Stone’s legal troubles trace back to 2016, when Dan and Mindy Straker of Bucyrus enlisted him to seek answers in the suspicious death of their son. Believing local authorities had not done enough, they relied on Stone to press forward. As a relatively new attorney, he initially pushed for reviews and pursued a wrongful death lawsuit, but when those efforts failed, he did not fully communicate the outcomes.
Over the following years, Stone’s behavior escalated from malpractice to outright deceit. He repeatedly misled the family with fabricated updates and false assurances that state investigators were actively pursuing the case. At times, he told them an indictment had been issued or that a special grand jury was being convened, none of which was true. He went so far as to impersonate other attorneys and officials, created false documents, and maintained an elaborate facade.
Evidence presented in court showed Stone arranged fictitious meetings with prosecutors, fabricated progress reports, and even had the Strakers babysit his children while misleading them about developments. He also solicited thousands of dollars from them under false pretenses, including roughly $7,500 for an expert analysis that was never conducted. For years, the Strakers were left believing justice for their son was around the corner, when in reality nothing was happening.
Investigations, Discipline, and Indictment
By 2022, the truth began to surface. A disciplinary complaint was filed with the Ohio Supreme Court’s Disciplinary Counsel, and Stone resigned his law license, citing mental health struggles. Around the same time, the Strakers pursued civil litigation, resulting in a judgment against Stone for negligence and fraud.
In late 2024, a Delaware County Grand Jury indicted Stone on four felony counts: telecommunications fraud, impersonating a peace officer, grand theft, and identity fraud. He was arraigned in January 2025, initially pleaded not guilty, and was released pending trial.
Plea Deal and Sentencing
On July 14, 2025, Stone pleaded guilty to telecommunications fraud and an amended charge of impersonation of an officer. In exchange, the other charges were dismissed, and restitution to the Strakers was agreed upon.
During sentencing, his attorneys argued that his actions were the result of poor judgment, personal struggles, and misplaced loyalty rather than greed. They emphasized his lack of prior criminal history, his resignation from the legal profession, and the personal hardships already endured, urging community control and probation.
Prosecutors, however, argued that his conduct inflicted deep emotional harm, exploited the Strakers’ grief, and amounted to a calculated, years-long fraud. They called for a prison term that reflected the seriousness of the crimes and the breach of trust by an attorney.
On August 26, 2025, Judge Schuck sentenced Stone to 36 months on the telecommunications fraud count and 18 months on the impersonation count, to be served consecutively. The ruling also affirmed restitution for the Strakers. Stone was taken into custody immediately following the hearing.
Conclusion
Stone’s case marks a dramatic fall from a once-prominent local attorney to a convicted felon. For the Straker family, it closes a painful chapter in their pursuit of justice for their son, though their original questions remain unanswered. Stone will now spend the next four and a half years in prison, with restitution still owed to his victims.
